The Point Live: Government to sign off on rushed draconian defence laws, while gas reservation debate continues with the Greens. As it happens.
Amy Remeikis – Chief Political Analyst and Political Blogger
The last sign off on the draconian defence laws which have been rammed through the parliament will happen early Monday, while the government turns to its digital duty of care and gas reservation legislation through the senate with the Greens. All the day's parliament events, with fact checks, live.
Dodgy oil & gas company got $6.5m grant despite “no evidence” for claims
Rod Campbell
If you apply for government money and you’re a researcher, or an artist or a community group, you know that you will have to bend over backwards to show that your project stacks up. And rightly so, because public money is valuable.
But that’s not how it works for the oil and gas industry and its favourite boondoggle, carbon capture and storage.
Newly released Freedom of Information documents from 2024 show that an oil and gas company was granted $6.5 million from the Commonwealth Government despite having shown “no evidence” that its project was viable. Here’s the key snip from page 122:
Despite this, Pilot Energy was granted $6.5 million in 2024. It then went broke in July 2026, leaving behind a $200 million clean up bill, as covered by great WA sources like Boiling Cold and WA Conservation Council.
Who is responsible for this? Who recommended the grant? Who was on the five-member Merit Assessment Committee with “relevant industry experience and policy expertise”?
Unfortunately, that’s all redacted.
Absolutely zero accountability.
This wouldn’t be good enough for a public school parents committee, but somehow it is fine for oil and gas companies and the government departments that subsidise them.
07.49 AEDT
The market bets the next rate move will be a cut
Greg Jericho
When parliament last sat, the RBA had yet to raise the cash rate to 4.85% (that happened on 3 November). But back then the market was not only pretty sue that there would be a rate rise on Melbourne Cup Day, but that thee was around a 50:50 chance that there might be another riser to 5.1% by the middle of next year.
These expectations had dimmed a bit by last Wednesday (18 Nov). The market was predicting no real likelihood of a rate rise in the near future but could see a rate cut within 18 months.
And then the October unemployment figures came out and the 4.9% shocked the hell out of investors.
By the next day the market had ruled out any chance of another rate rise and was predicting a rate cut by August next year and 2 within 18 months.
This of course does not mean it will happen. The market has had some belief after the September unemployment figures showed it hitting 4.7% that the RBA would stop raising rates. And The Andrew Hauser, the Deputy Governor gave a “fireside chat” in which he all but told the markets the RBA would likely raise rates in November.
Let us hope this time the market is correct, because it is pretty clear the RBA has got it wrong.
When it made its decision on 3 November to raise rates its forecast was for unemployment not to reach 4.9% until December next year.
While it’s always a very optimistic list (less ‘take with a grain of salt’ and more ‘based on a true story’ areas) it does still give a good indication of what the Government is hoping to pass.
But as ever, once agreement is reached on any legislation (listed here or not) the Government is desperate to pass, you’ll likely see the bill rammed through before anyone can change their mind.
While there are more bills listed than those below (you can take a look at the full list here), here’s the most interesting legislation listed for the week:
Passing this bill in this final sitting week will be the Government’s primary goal, and so it’s no surprise to see it up first on Monday. Debate on this bill will go for as long as the negotiations do, so while everyone involved sounds like they are working constructively and negotiations are progressing smoothly, don’t be surprised if this bill drags into Tuesday.
We promise this is much more interesting than it sounds. Really.
You can read Clare Ozich’s op-ed in The Point on DGR reform here. Justice Connect along with a coalition of other groups including LINA (Local and Independent News Association) are calling for reforms to the Deductible Gift Recipient (DGR) system, in line with the recommendations of the 2024 philanthropy inquiry.
listing this is VERY optimistic, bordering on magical thinking of the Government, but the PHI bill that was discharged from the notice paper by the Senate in October, is listed for Thursday.
I’d say that if the PHI bill manages to pass the Senate this, I’ll eat my hat, but it’s too soon. Vale Fiona the Hippo. <3
07.46 AEDT
On COP31’s collapse
Chris Bowen has taken ‘his share’ of the responsibility for the climate talks collapsing without a deal.
I take my share of responsibility. Ultimately, you know, people can judge what could have been done or couldn’t have been done. Ultimately, it’s a party-driven process, and ultimately, parties chose not to seek an agreement.
Amy Westervelt and Royce Kurmelovs for Drilled have written some of the best coverage of COP31 and you should check it out.
You can find some of their latest, here, which helps explain how we got to this point. Usually the COP will come up with an agreement that is wishy washy and as stable as a sodden paper towel, but there is an agreement. There is no agreement here, which is rare, but also mask off for Big Oil.
There was a first draft of the agreement, which had ending fossil fuels all over it. And about three or four days later when the new agreement came out, there was no mention of ending fossil fuels. Saudi Arabia led the push with other fossil fuel nations to make sure fossil fuels weren’t mentioned and WHAT DO YOU KNOW it worked. So then the other nations which at least pretend to care about this stuff (even if they won’t pay for it) said they could not sign an agreement that did not cover fossil fuels.
And here we are. But hey – Barnaby Joyce has feelings, and that’s what matters right?
07.38 AEDT
PM press conference
Anthony Albanese has called a press conference for 8am. Mark Butler will be joining him.
Labor is focusing on health for this coming election, so you will be seeing a lot of Butler over the next year or so.
07.36 AEDT
Off the rails before 8am
Barnaby Joyce then goes on a rant about getting rid of all climate policy, which I am sure plays really well in the sorts of circles Joyce likes to surround himself by, and when asked for the cost of what he would replace it with, goes on a rant about capacity schemes.
He then says ‘private investment’ will cover it. Which – lol. Sure. Let’s get more private investment owning energy costs in a time of great global uncertainty where nations without the ability to turn to their own power source are getting screwed.
Energy security is national security. Someone should make Barnaby Joyce aware of that.
The ‘debate’ goes completely off the rails and honestly, I don’t know who is being served here, but it’s no one watching.
07.32 AEDT
Barnaby Joyce has some feelings.
Now the host is pretending the $150m Australia spent on the talks meant something to the economy and whether it is responsible in a cost of living crisis. You know what is not responsible? Letting the planet COOK.
$150m in a $2 trillion economy is like couch change. The best way to think about government spending in real terms, is:
A million = $100.
Obviously this isn’t an exact science, but you get my drift. It isn’t a huge amount of money to a government budget. It’s a rounding error.
But $150m seems like a lot of money so that’s the new flash point.
Plibersek:
Well, we need to do both. This is not an either or. We need to work out. And one of the reasons that we have these climate conferences is to work out what our future energy mix looks like.
We got additional investment from Korea and Denmark into renewables in Australia, because we’re at the climate conference and just I mean, you talk about the Reserve Bank, we’ve just had a deputy, former deputy of the Reserve Bank, Guy Debelle, say that the fact that we’re moving so substantially to renewables in Australia means that our energy prices are 30 to 50% lower than they would otherwise be.
We’ve actually seen a 27% drop in wholesale energy prices, because we’re moving to renewables in Barnaby’s electorate. In New England, that means a retail price drop between 5 and 7%, we’ve got 4 million Australians who’ve worked this out. They’ve put solar panels on the roof because they know their energy bills go down with renewables. There’s 600,000 people have now got batteries as well.
Those people have reduced their energy bills to just about zero because they’ve invested in renewables, as we have as a nation.
And that just clears the way for Barnaby Joyce (who only recently stated he was not Jesus when asked for some details on a policy he was pushing) to be Barnaby Joyce:
Chris Brown’s not the most frustrated.Person in Australia.I’ll tell you what. Small businesses, pensioners, people who are going broke, they’re the most frustrated people now. I just read he about he couldn’t get to sleep. Chris Brown couldn’t get to sleep because he was worried about the plenary session in Antalya worried about what?
I’d rather worrying about what happens in the plenary plenary room in….worry about what happens in the kitchen table room in Australia. (Also known as the kitchen)
That’s what you should be worrying about. The people who can’t pay their power bills, the families who can’t afford to get ahead, the deindustrialisation of Australia, this ridiculous wind panels…you know, wind towers, solar panels, transmission lines destroying our countryside. Yeah. New England would love to have a yarn to you about what you’re doing to New England energy.
Notice how coal pits are never destroying the country side? And people who have solar farms and wind farms on their property are compensated. It’s passive income. Renters don’t have a choice about whether or not there is solar panels on their property, and we don’t have a choice about whether the planet continues to heat up, but hey – Joyce has some feelings, so we must platform those!
07.25 AEDT
No deal on climate in COP31. But it’s not like the planet is cooking right?
Tanya Plibersek is made to continue the worst job in politics ‘debating’ Barnaby Joyce on the Seven Network once a week. She is asked about the climate talk failures, and whether as president of negotiations, Chris Bowen, and Australia, have to accept responsibility.
(One of the main issues was no one wanted to pay for the transition. Our future generations, if they are that many, will be looking at us very, very contemptuously and rightly so. But it’s not just our kids and their kids – it is us too. We are feeling the impacts of this every year. Not sure why the world’s leaders get let off so lightly on all of this, or why we are even debating it)
Plibersek:
Climate change is a global problem, and it’s only by countries coming together that we can actually address it properly. Even Matt Canavan said that last year, and I’m sure Barnaby would agree that if we’re going to take action to reduce carbon emissions, Australia can’t be the only country doing it.
We have to work with countries all around the world. It’s important for us in Australia to do that. It’s also really important for our Pacific neighbours who are at the front line of having their countries washed away and swallowed up by rising ocean levels. It’s important for our farmers, you know, when there is a big drought in Australia, as there inevitably will be again in a few years time, it’s our farmers who cop it worst of all and that affects all of us. It flows through into food prices. So it is in our interests to work with other nations to tackle what is a global problem.
It’s frustrating that we didn’t get further. I’m sure Chris is, you know, the most frustrated person I can think of right now because he put many hours, weeks into these negotiations and really wanted to see something of an improvement on where we are now globally. But there’s no country that can do this on its own. And without coming together, we can’t advance those talks.
By the way – Australia refuses to count it’s exported emissions, so we pretend we are lowering emissions when we aren’t. We want to increase them. And shockingly, planting trees, when our existing trees are already choking on the current emissions, is not going to ‘off-set’ diddly squat.
07.16 AEDT
Good morning!
Hello and welcome to the last sitting week for the year.
The Point editor Anna Chang has created a playlist for the team which is just ‘One Day More’ three times before the big crescendo, so we are all feeling it at the moment.
And I have to say, I am not feeling particularly warm and fuzzy about the going ons in the federal parliament – the last tick off for the most draconian defence laws in about 50 years will be moved through the house today, after some small amendments were made to the defence capability act in the senate.
But the government has already agreed to those amendments, so the laws can not be stopped. You can read more about what they do here, here,here and here, but just a reminder they were passed with about 30 minutes of debate. And almost NO mainstream media coverage.
Which shouldn’t be overly surprising – there is no political ‘fight’ here – both Labor and the Coalition thought the laws, which will give Defence the power to ban protest, give public servants the power to override state, territory and commonwealth laws and give defence contractors, including foreign nationals, the power to seize, search and detain people, including with dogs if they do or are suspected of a ‘thing’ or having ‘a thing’ (they literally list ‘a thing’ in the legislation) as well as send people to jail for taking a photo – whether they know it’s a defence ‘zone’ or not – are just fine and dandy. So there was no push and pull, no two-horse race.
It passed in the House on the voices, which means they didn’t even go to a division on it. Just a ayyyyyeeee and then it was off to the senate.
I mean, a lot of Labor MPs didn’t seem to know what the bill did. And it’s not like journalists read legislation any more (I only found the bill after going back through the hansard to see if I had missed anything when senate estimates was sitting, and then thought some of the language in the introductory speech by Peter Khalil was weird, so went and read the actual bill and hooooooboy)
And now the gallery is turning to the ‘fights’ on the digital duty of care and the gas reservation bill. So you’ll plenty on that, but not on laws that take away powers from the states and territories to have their laws considered (and it’s mostly environmental and native title laws which will be wiped away with the flick of a public servant’s fingers here) and people keep their civil liberties.
COOOL BEANS.
So yeah, not heading into this week with a lot of optimism. And if you have been following COP31, like Royce Kurmelovs has, you’ll be even less optimistic. Because the discussions, over which Australia has some actual influence as a co-host (small, but still – some actual control and influence) are on the brink of collapse. As we see the planet’s temperature increasing.
The EU rejects #COP31 cover decision: "We will not endorse a cover decision or an Italia pact that does not even mention fossil fuels, which is the key driver of climate change. And we will not accept negotiating backward in time. And we will not accept a COP that greenwashes fossil fuel."
Talking of greenwashing fossil fuel – that is what Australia did at those talks. And even as the talks collapse, there was not a single mention of ‘climate’ on Insiders on Sunday. Which is not surprising, because there was not a single question to Richard Marles, who was the interview, about the sweeping defence law powers he circulated in his name.
Again. COOOOLLLLLL BEANNNNNSSSSS.
So join me in the descent to whatever layer of Dante’s Circle I make it to. There will be cake, and coffee. I am on number three right now. Hope you’ll join me. One. Day. More.
Comments (1)
-
Fiona
Mon, 23.11.26
07.29 AEDT
Join the conversation
Morning lovely
Stay cool